Ask Betty!

Do you have any cooking questions
or need a cooking tip?
Send a question and I will try to answer.

Ask Betty

Substituting Butter for Shortening

I have several cookie recipes I would like to try but they all call for shortening (which I have never used in anything, and can't imagine ever using!). Can I use butter instead and get the same results? What about in pie crust? Thanks for all your help in the past - you are the greatest! --Nana Ruth
Oh Nana Ruth, we’re getting into a little bit of tricky territory here, but yes, you can usually substitute butter if shortening is called for in baking recipes. For every 1 cup of shortening in the recipe, use 1 cup + 2 tablespoons butter. But note that using butter instead of shortening will make cookies less crunchy--but probably better tasting! As for pie crusts, if the recipe calls for shortening, you can use butter (in the ratio I mention above), but the crust will turn out less tender than if you used shortening. Since butter is much more flavorful than shortening, many bakers compromise by using half butter and half shortening (or lard) in pie crust dough, giving a good-tasting AND tender crust.

What Others Have To Say

Thank you for the advice of subtituting butter for shortening and the results you get in the difference.

  • Question

    Do you have a good recipe for zucchini bread that you can share with everyone?

    —Cherie

    April 2012
  • Question
    I need a recipe for gingerbread boy cookies. --Naomi
    March 2012
  • Question

    Please add a couple macaroni salad recipes. I recently had one that was simply delicious, and prior to that I had not been a fan. It seemed to have a taste of onion, but not too overpowering, a smattering of green pepper finely chopped, celery, green peas, a bit of finely diced carrots (not quite shredded, but very small) and hard boiled egg. The dressing was mayo based rather than miracle whip, but it had some spices I did not readily identify, but it was wonderful. Thx.

    —Kathryn

    May 2012
  • Question
    Does anyone make a good, simple marble cake today? It's what I always wanted on my birthday, and now, if you try and get one, it's a special order. --Mike
    March 2012
  • Question
    Do you have a blueberry pie for my grampa? --Willy
    March 2012
  • Question

    Please add a recipe for meat loaf.
    --Denise

    April 2012
  • Question
    My kids get tired of sandwiches--any suggestions for some different lunches to pack for school? --Amanda
    March 2012
  • Question
    I am looking for recipes for tilapia. --Amy
    March 2012
  • Question
    How do you measure 3/4 cup of sugar or cranberries? What is 3/8 teaspoon of salt? --Vanessa
    March 2012
  • Question
    I had a recipe from Grandmas and this weekend I took it to the store with me and lost it. I have all of the ingredients and was so excited to try the recipe again. I looked on the website and it is not there. Do you still have the Chicken Stroganoff recipe? Where can I find it? Thanks. --Katherine
    March 2012
10/25/11
Pin It print
TAGS:
Join Grandma's new Oven-Lovin League

FREE Membership entitles you to
fresh-from-the-oven club privileges:

  • Thousands of Kitchen-Tested Recipes
  • Exclusive Cooking Tips from Grandma Betty
  • Member-Only Merchandise Discounts
Join Now! It's Free!