Collections of Recipes
Grandma's Selections
Recipes by Course
Recipes by Season
Ask Betty!
Do you have any cooking questionsor need a cooking tip?
Send a question and I will try to answer.
Ask Betty
- Do you have recipes for beef fondue?
- I would like to make coleslaw like I had when I was a kid. What is the dressing for the coleslaw made with? Thank you...
- I'm looking for an easy carrot cake recipe that won't be to complicated to make. Cream cheese frosting recipe would be...
- Could you please add a recipe for apple butter? – Lynn
Substituting Butter for Shortening
I have several cookie recipes I would like to try but they all call for shortening (which I have never used in anything, and can't imagine ever using!). Can I use butter instead and get the same results? What about in pie crust? Thanks for all your help in the past - you are the greatest!
--Nana Ruth
Oh Nana Ruth, we’re getting into a little bit of tricky territory here, but yes, you can usually substitute butter if shortening is called for in baking recipes. For every 1 cup of shortening in the recipe, use 1 cup + 2 tablespoons butter. But note that using butter instead of shortening will make cookies less crunchy--but probably better tasting!
As for pie crusts, if the recipe calls for shortening, you can use butter (in the ratio I mention above), but the crust will turn out less tender than if you used shortening. Since butter is much more flavorful than shortening, many bakers compromise by using half butter and half shortening (or lard) in pie crust dough, giving a good-tasting AND tender crust.

-
QuestionMy Grandmother cooked these wonderful "cookies" called teacakes. Do you have a recipe for them? --DianneMarch 2012
-
QuestionI got a recipe card in the mail many years ago and it's the only banana bread I will ever make again. I wanted to share it with friends as a holiday gift and was hoping to find it on here so I could just send a link. Thank you. --DixieMarch 2012
-
QuestionHow do you cook corn on the cob on the BBQ grill? --BruceMarch 2012
-
QuestionDo you have a recipe for eggnog pound cake? --PriscillaMarch 2012
-
Question
Do you have a recipe for chicken and dumplings?
—DebbieMay 2012 -
Question
What is the reason for a cake to come out too crumbly? Is it because of over beating or keeping the batter out for long time or is it because of too much baking soda? I baked a carrot cake; it was so soft and crumbly that it fell below the resting tray!
--SabithaJune 2012 -
QuestionNeed some recipes for turkey burgers; thank you. --RoseMarch 2012
-
Question
Please add a recipe for meat loaf.
--DeniseApril 2012 -
Question
Hi Betty. I'm looking for a really good, but not too terribly hard, date bar recipe. Thanks for any help you can give me. Have a great day.
—Susan
May 2012 -
Question
Grandma, I love to grill and would like to know how I can make my food taste a little more interesting. Do you know a good recipe for a marinade? –Michael
August 2012






What Others Have To Say
Thank you for the advice of subtituting butter for shortening and the results you get in the difference.